Hometown Bias: The lack of credibility (updated)

In our previous blog we posted an editorial that was published in the Mat-Su Valley Frontiersman regarding the recent indictments of U.S. Senator Ted Stevens.

The editorial is highly critical of Senator Stevens which is their right, but it also highlights how highly biased this newspaper has become when the issue is ethics in politics and when it comes to covering the actions of their hometown governor.

Last fall when Wasilla Mayor Dianne Keller was accused of abusing her power by trying to pressure local business owners to give in to demands concerning a right of way for a local developer, the Frontiersman was like a dog with a bone.

First they strongly supported an investigation into the matter advocating that the facts needed to be vetted about these serious charges.

Then when the investigation was completed and a local law firm found their was questionable behavior but a local district attorney found there was not enough evidence to charge the mayor, they ran an editorial demanding Keller resign.

In a June 22 editorial they wrote: 

In the end, Keller lacks credibility, sincerity and accountability. None of these traits engender trust and confidence in a city’s leader.

That Keller believes she has done no wrong and has tried to explain away her actions as looking out for the safety of Valley residents smacks of former President Bill Clinton debating the definition of “is.”

Mayor Keller, step down now.

 

However, the current contrast appears to be that while the Frontiersman was a strong  advocate of getting to the facts surrounding the Keller situation and endorsing an  independent investigation, they have abandoned that same level of advocacy with regards to other politicians. 

Aside from convicting Sen. Stevens in their editorial before his day in court, when the news broke about the legislature voting unanimously to investigate allegations that Governor Sarah Palin's staff and her husband illegally pressured former Department of Public Safety Commissioner Walt Monegan, they didn't print one word.

And when the news broke about former district attorney Steve Branchflower being hired to handle the investigation into the Palin adminsitration, again.... dead silence.

And when the news broke about 78 pages of emails that the open and transparent government of their hometown governor refused to release as part of a freedom of information act, including a few dozen that were copied to the governor's husband but yet the public were denied, the Frontiersman seemed to lose all of their keyboards.

But the along comes the indictments of U.S. Senator Ted Stevens and once again the Frontiersman conveniently finds their step stool to climb up on their high ethical horse. 

This morning's Mat-Su Valley Frontiersman editorial highlights yet again just how tainted the glasses these folks are wearing to view the state of affairs.

In the opening sentence of their editorial they write, "Following last week’s approval of TransCanada’s license to build a 1,700-mile natural gas pipeline to tap into Alaska’s vast reserves.."

Excuse me, but no such license was granted.

The so called "AGIA license" doesn't allow TransCanada to build anything; it simply allows them to take advantage of getting a $500 million subsidy from the state and exclusive contractual rights, none of which give it the ability to actually "build a 1,700-mile natural gas pipeline." 

Maybe the Frontiersman missed the big story yesterday when TransCanada's CEO stated that the pipeline wouldn't be built without the same companies that their hometown governor's AGIA plan was designed to ignore.

Yeah...maybe they were busy trying to find their keyboards in the newsroom.

 

June 22, 2008 editorial:

http://www.frontiersman.com/articles/2008/06/22/opinion/editorials/doc485e05ac1ec3d029971510.txt


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Andrew, I have to agree but...

As a resident of the valley, I have to agree that the Frontiersman has for the most part generated op-ed pieces that portray the Governor in the most favorable light and often ignored her policy or behavioral stumbles. Of course, they have not been the only media purveyors finding themselves guilty of this trend. In a recent Legislative Digest Bulletin, Tim Bradner remarked that in part, Palin’s recent behaviors of executive excess may have been exacerbated and enabled in part because the news media kept giving her slack and Palin kept taking up the slack until she found herself “out of bounds”. Acting as a voice of the people, the media does have responsibility to hold elected officials accountable for their actions. In defense of the Frontiersman, however, I do have to say, they have allowed me a strong voice in their paper over the last year. I cannot say the same for ADN. On Jan. 25, 2008, the Frontiersman did publish my guest editorial regarding the Palin/KWHL on Lyda Green, b***** interview. And again on June, 22, 2008, when I took Palin to task for not acknowledging or signing Sen. Green’s prescription drug data base bill. I do believe, I even characterized Palin as a “fence sitting panderer”. In conclusion, they may not be perfect but they have afforded an open forum for the opinion of others when they have appeared to be squeamish to do so themselves.


Following last week’s

Following last week’s approval of TransCanada’s license to build a 1,700-mile natural gas pipeline to tap into Alaska’s vast reserves. The Frontiersman never lets the facts get in the way of a good story. Only FERC can grant the license to build.


Hometown Bias Indeed...

It’s pretty rich to read Halcro whining about “bias” on a forum other than his own. There isn’t a blog out there that is more biased than what we see from ol’ Don Quixote Halcro. The VoiceoftheCrimes.net is probably a close second. I don’t live out in the Valley, however with the situation of Keller… Andrew seems to conveniently gloss over the fact that the call for Keller to step down came AFTER, yes after, the investigation was completed. Clearly that is an act of overt bias from the Frontiersmen?? Who in their right mind would wait until an investigation is completed before coming to conclusions about a politician!?? Pointing this out will probably merit some sort of smarmy remark at the end of this post from Adrea like I drank the kool-aid, or I’m a “Palinista,” and/or “Palin-bot.” But believe it or not, I do believe that our Senior Senator deserves the same treatment; that we should reserve judgment until the facts are proven… after all aren’t we all afforded the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty??? Or is it that we are innocent until indicted/investigated? Halcro wants to pick and choose which politician gets crucified before all the facts come out... and then criticize others who don’t agree with his views. It seems to me that there is an inherent “Hometown Bias” shining through.

..I'm not advocating anyone should jump to conclusions before the facts are vetted. I strongly believe that an independent investigation or in Stevens case, a trial by a jury of his peers should happen before we issue judgement.

I don't disagree with your comments about the Frontiersman calling for Keller's resignation after the investigation was done. That's proper. 

However, my point was that they were advocates for the investigation to be done initially to draw out the facts of the matter, which is in contrast to recent situations.

I'm simply saying the Frontiersman has taken an inconsistent stance in advocating the need for the facts to come out in  ethics related investigations.

I have updated the blog to make it more clear.

AH


No Smarmy remarks You @$#&$#@#

Andrew, I give you credit for attempting a pretty rational response to an irrational submittal. Analytical(tnat has to be a joke) spends half the note trying to think of clever hurtful names to call you and then obsesses about what "smarmy" references someone might make in response to their goofy rant. We let these folks vote and drive cars ??? At the end of the day it is just sad that the management of the Frontiersman, ADN and KTUU don't have any real interest in the truth. It is hard to think that all these communication businesses are made up of our neighbors and yet they go to work everyday to a job where they leave their integrity at the door and do whatever they are told including burying the truth in the interest of political agendas and/or currying favor with a vindictive Governor and her family.


"Anonymous" Go love yourself

... maybe you should be annointed to pick and choose who gets to vote (and drive) in this State and who does not. Your's is a completely rational submittal for sure.


Yet Another Example

Yet another example of why we have Sara and Todd driving our great state into the ground and the highest insurance rates in the country.


It

really is too bad. I ran out of smarmy over the weekend.


Managing Editor of the Frontiersman

Greg Johnson is the managing editor of the Frontiersman. He needs to get your calls and emails to remind him what a reporter is supposed to do.
Phone: 907-352-2268
Email: Greg Johnson


Bias

The reason is because the frontiersman is all to familiar with Governor Cupcakes' little black book of blacklisted companies and people. Turn on her, or say no just once and you (or your company) ends up on that list and you are nothing but dirt after that, and will never be called on again. There are dozens of businesses and individuals in the Valley that could attest to that. The Frontiersman is just plain terrified of being "listed".


YUP....JUST LIKE THE FRONTIERSMAN

has not printed one word of the governor's pet project the NEW dairy in the Valley having 30,000 lbs of cheese tainted with E. Coli, Listeria and Staph! A huge concern for lives and public safety. Why not a word???????????


copyright 2007 Andrew Halcro, All Rights Reserved.