Time To Go Tom!

BECOME A FAN OF FIRE TOM IRWIN ON FACEBOOK

fblogo

 

Todd's Deposition: A Dud from the Dude

NEW! Subscribe to RSS Feed

                                 Coming Thursday: The Shadow Governor

After complaining for the last five weeks about how politics and the media had taken over the intended bi-partisan investigation into Governor Palin's firing of former Department of Public Safety Commissioner Walt Monegan, Todd Palin's deposition was leaked to the media on the same day it was delivered to special investigator Steve Branchflower. 

Apparently the first dude was trying to get out in front of a fast moving train.

In his 25 page response, Palin covers old ground about his concerns about State Trooper Mike Wooten and events that occurred years before his wife was elected governor. In fact what Palin's deposition shows is a guy who isn't concerned about the safety of his family, it's about a guy who is trying to get even and trying to use the power of his wife's office to accomplish the task.

We've broken down some of the more curious responses and half truths in his depositions, many of which we written about over the last few months.

Page 1, Line 17: "(Wooten) illegally shot a cow moose without a permit"

Palin of course leaves out the fact that his entire family knew the moose was shot illegally in 2003 but that didn't stop him and his family from butchering and eating the meat, only to file the complaint two years later when Wooten was divorcing Sarah's sister.

Page 2, Line 16: "In 2005 and 2006, State Trooper Mike Wooten was the subject of a court ordered domestic violence protective order."

Palin of course leaves out the fact that the order was granted while Wooten was out of state taking his step son to Portland. While he was away, Sarah Palin and her sister went before a judge in Palmer and convinced the judge to grant the order without any evidence of domestic violence. Upon his return, Anchorage Judge John Suddock questioned Palin's sister and immediately revoked the order, calling it an egregious abuse of the legal system. 

Page 3, Line 1: "Threats against a public official, and his or her family, fall within the responsibilities of the Department of Public Safety."

True. But the last complaint of any threat occurred over a year before Governor Palin was elected.

In fact, once the divorce was final in early 2006, there were no more complaints or concerns voiced officially against Trooper Wooten. 

By the time Palin was elected governor, the Wooten issue was all over except for Todd's obsession.

Page 3, Line 13: "I was not aware of the Grimes report until July 2008, after Monegan left the government."

This is a blatant untruth. Monegan made it very clear that Wooten had already been punished and that is why he couldn't take any further action unless Wooten made another mistake. This is exactly why Monegan kept pushing back when pressured because he legally couldn't take any retro-active action against an employee who had already been punished because it would have violated Wooten's employee rights.

Page 4, Line 3: "I had hundreds of conversations and communications about Trooper Wooten over the last several years with my family, friends, with colleagues, just about everyone I could including government officials."

In a July 18, 2008 press release, Governor Palin stated; “To allege that I, or any member of my family....directed disciplinary action be taken against any employee of the Department of Public Safety, is, quite simply, outrageous.

But yet according to Todd Palin's deposition he complained about Trooper Mike Wooten to Mike Tibbles, Randy Ruaro, Ivey Frye, Frank Bailey, Mike Nizich, John Bitney, John Glass and Audie Holloway. 

In addition, during an interview with former Legislative Liason John Bitney last July, he said, "People don't know just how much weight Todd's words have. When Todd Palin makes a suggestion, it's not really a suggestion."

Having this many conversations, over two years after the last interaction with Wooten shows a pattern of Palin's obsession with getting even with Wooten.

Page 5, Line 3: "I make no apologies for wanting to protect my family and wanting to publicize the injustice of a violent Trooper keeping his badge."

This comment makes no sense when considered in the scope of his actions.

First, his family was never in danger. In fact a few months ago Governor Palin felt safe enough on her own to become the first governor to ever discontinue her security detail. Does that really sound like someone who is concerned about a rogue trooper patrolling the neighborhood?

Second, Todd Palin didn't publicize anything. In fact this didn't even become public until Monegan got fired and we broke the story on this blog.

If this really was a case of a "violent trooper keeping his badge", why in the world hasn't the governor done anything to protect the public? Why didn't she hold a press conference and talk about the need to protect the public's safety or introduce legislation or even offer an amendment to any number of suitable pieces of legislation that were making their way through the legislative process?

Why didn't Governor Palin do something, anything, to change the way Trooper's investigate their own to protect the public against future rogue troopers?

The answer is simple; this wasn't about the public being at risk, it was about the Palin's getting even.

Page 5, Line 18: "It is tragic that because Trooper Wooten told a false story to a blogger who repeated it, the legislature has allocated over $100,000 of public money to harass me and numerous other innocents."

Other innocents? Like Frank Bailey who in a recorded phone call to State Trooper Rodney Dial was trying to get Trooper Wooten fired and inferred he was calling on behalf of Todd and Sarah Palin?

In a taped interview with Anchorage Daily News Reporter Kyle Hopkins on August 14, Governor Palin stated unequivocally that Frank Bailey acted completely on his own.

"No one ever directed him to make any calls, he never disclosed he made any calls," Governor Palin said. 

However this turned out to be not true.

On February 29, an email was sent from Frank Bailey to Ivy Frye just after Bailey's recorded phone call to Trooper Dial.

"Leaving pretty quick for the airport...call me though I need to give you a heads up. Spoke to Rodney and he doesn't get that kind of stuff since he's a Lieutenant, but he'd definitely pass it on."

Not only that, but Palin also told Hopkins that "Todd never told Frank Bailey or suggest he take on this mission to call a trooper."

However according to state phone logs, Todd Palin called Ivy Frye three times between 1:45pm and 3:50pm on the afternoon of February 28, the day before Bailey's call to Dial.

This set off a flurry of emails which included Todd Palin in the loop and only ended a little more than an hour after Bailey called to try and get Wooten fired.

Then, after all this, Bailey reportedly has testified that the confidential information he received regarding Wooten's personnel file that he passed along to Trooper Dial came from none other than Todd Palin.

Page 12, Lines 1 through 14, Palin talked about how he and the governor were frustrated with Monegan because whenever they need to use the Department of Public Safety King Air, it was always busy.

"We were concerned that the Department of Public Safety was retaliating against Sarah for selling the Murkowski jet that Department of Public Safety officials enjoyed using." 

Just one big problem with this assertion; the jet was put on the block before any of Palin's Public Safety Officials could use it. Ironically, Palin has been using the sale of the jet to promote her fiscal prowess on the national stage, telling Americans she sold it on ebay because the department and Alaska didn't need it.

Page 12, Lines 22 to 25: There was an email on June 30, 2008 from Monegan that had the annual AST 2007 report. I was aware that Sarah was not happy with the report. Sarah was having difficulty finding out who had authored it and who was going to take responsibility for it."

The report, which outlined the state crime statistics for 2007 was compiled by the public safety department. In an interview with the Anchorage Daily News in August, Monegan spoke about delivering the annual DPS crime report to Governor Palin where she replied, "This makes me look bad."

It's understandable why according to Todd, "Sarah was not happy with the report", it showed crime was increasing significantly in Alaska under her watch as governor.

The fact that Todd states that she wanted to know who authored it and who was going to take responsibility for it shows just how out of touch she is as governor.

As governor, the buck is stops with her. She is ultimately responsible for the rising rates of crime in Alaska, especially since she has made a fuss about trying to cut the budget at DPS.

This again makes the point that some have made for two years; this administration has been focused more on public relations than public policy....or in this case, public safety.

To see the entire deposition:

http://i.cdn.turner.com/cnn/2008/images/10/08/todd.palin.10.08.08.pdf


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Palin's Abuse of Power

So when does the Recall start? Or perhaps the Impeachment? It doesn't look like Palin will be going to Washington come January, and those of us in the lower 48 are happy to ship her home to you.


Oh Todd

Most excellent move on your part. I do hope you realize the problem you have. Because when it is Wooden's turn in the batter' box, your toast. Get your checkbook out and start writting. Oh, and by the way, the legislature's report is out. So now we know, that you both are bold faced liars. How's it feel to have your world blow up around you?


Dirty backroom politics!

Dirty politics! Dirty politics! What else is in force to win votes? People with vindictive minds are reaking havoc just to get their favorite person into office and they will dig up any kind of dirt they can and call it "justifying our political ethics". I won't say who I am voting for but I can say "Who ever said our government was perfect?". If we were all perfect we wouldn't need government officials. Just like traffic lights were created to keep down confusion on the streets government was created to keep confusion off of main street. More power to ANYONE who wants to protect their family, office or state. What is wrong with that?!!!!!! He who has never sinned (made a mistake and etc.) let him/her cast the first stone. Our court room walls say "In God we trust". Whoever gets into office will need the backing and prayer of every voter and supporter. All men are imperfect but there is one perfect creator who is over all. ~I am the sixth cousin to George Washington and third great grandaughter to Col. John Almus Garnder (Senator and Lawyer).


Thanks for letting us all

Thanks for letting us all know what's really going on up there in Alaska. Some media outlets aren't able to give us reliable background information on the Palins. If McCain had truly vetted McCain, you would have been included in his questioning. Keep letting us know the truth!!!


Todd & Sarah Palin personal communications?

Andrew, Many elected officials use their spouses as sounding boards and support or non-support for that matter. Some say in the waining years of the Regan administration that Nancy was the communicator for Prez Regan due to advancement of Alziemhers.(sp) I see nothing unusual or wrong with Governor Palin discussing issues with her spouse or anybody else that helps her make the best decisions necessary for the State of Alaska. I rely on this input from my family, because I know I can sometimes get off track and miss the meaning behind the issues. Nothing extraordinary here.


Keep To The Facts

This is about a 'corrupt' trooper, not about the AK State Troopers as a whole. There appears to be misinformation flying around that the AK State Troopers are corrupt. Stay on topic. Clearly there are those that feel the masses are corrupt, but keep things in perspective. Wooten's union is not going to go quietly, especially with the likes of John Cyr running the show. Wooten was/is a 'bad egg'. There is no justification for keeping someone on the payroll that clearly is a danger to the people. Palin may have pressured Monegan, but did Monegan completely do everything in his ability to correct the situation? Again, this is about a corrupt trooper that remains on the force (more tragic than a loss of a job or a sullied reputation).


keep to the facts

If we are going to keep to the facts,show me where it is that trooper wooten is a bad egg,so he had a bad divorce he isnt the first and probably not the last,who is he a danger too Palin because she said so,all the complaints were filed by them,not by any members of the public.So yes lets keep to the facts.Another fact is she praised him in a ref to get into the troopers,he was everything a cop should be but suddenly a fall from grace and he is a bad egg....whatever.


The aerial wolf hunter who cried wolf

Standing back for a bigger pictures, we see: 1. Rather than sticking to facts and disagreeing with policy, Sarah Palin puts on display her egregiously twisted version of who Barack Obama is. She is shameless in misrepresenting character, in manufacturing from the facts dangerously wrongheaded interpretations and conclusions, and is encouraging others to embrace these marginally vetted rantings and accept them at face value. One gets a sense from this one example of how she operates in general. We now witness Exhibit A of "ambitious woman twists facts for personal gain". Note the repeated theme of calling forth images of potential victimization at the hands of people who might in some way terrorize others (Americans; "my family"), and the fact that she has no shame about drawing even farfetched conclusions. Fast reverse to look to see if this pattern holds in the Wooten/Monegan situation. Looks for all the world to me like ANOTHER situation in which Palin, with neurotic muscularity, strains at credulity in branding Wooten.... essentially a terrorist, who is out to hurt her family. The examples often can't stand the light of truth(like Wooten's bagging a moose without a permit -- the Palins butchered and ate it, and then filed the complaint two years later at the time of Sarah's sister's divorce). So we see that this woman has a track record of questionable judgment and conclusions unsupported by facts in the case of Obama, and it colors the willingness to conclude that she used any judgment in the case of Monegan/Wooten. Based on the Obama baloney, all shreds of credibility in the Monegan firing and Wooten rationalization simply blow away in the wind. 2. Todd Palin's non-response "response" to Stephen Branchflowers interrogatories displays a man so arrogant and convinced of hiw own rightness and self importance, but also so intensely and densely entwined in his own explanations and rationalizations and stories, topped off with a strongly held sense of entitlement that he holds himself as blameless. Little does he know that what was written on his behalf speaks VOLUMES about his character, even as he tries to resahape the public opnion of him. If Palin had cooperated and answered some questions, the public would be more inclined to sympathy. He did not. That will neither wash nor wear well. I'm afraid the scales are tipping away from the benefit of the doubt, Todd. The wolfhunters are crying wolf once too often. But there's one more thing I'd like to contrast all this with: What about the rape victims in Wasilla, having to pay for their own rape kits (investigative tools of the police that should be paid for by the police)? The Palins' inordinate self-pity and inability to disengage from their own web of rationalization, and their inability to tease apart the personal from the political starkly contrasts with the nonexistent compassion for others' experience of actual violence, a moment where the political demands compassion and connection with the personal. Todd Palin's response evokes a gubercouple that is completely wrapped up in themselves and their beliefs and perceptions and high drama, including a boilerplate fear that others may harm them, but are fundamentally unable to connect with the plight of constituents against whom harm was not threatened, but was actually carried out. Weird and weirder.


Hats off to you

Hats off to you Andrew Wish all this had come out before she was chosen the first dude is damned scary No Insult to rednecks but is this what redneck power couple does she is more dangerous than bush


Are you Serious?

Do you have nothing else to do? You sound like you know what your talking about but really all you are doing is bashing someone for getting to an office you could not get to. Correct me if I am wrong but Alaska is an “At Will” state. The Governor should be able to fire anyone she feels is not doing their job. Would you be posting a blog if a CEO of a cooperation fired one of it’s managers for not meeting expectations? Really I think some people just want you to drop it.


It is a small detail in the

It is a small detail in the overall context, but I need to keep pointing out that Sarah doesn't fire people. She always sends staff members to do her dirty work so she doesn't have to look professional people in the eye when she ends their careers.


Surprised?

And I thought I was alone on this. I've been reading the blathering on this site for months and have found it trite and small-minded. At least you've been allowed to have your post placed on this site. Nearly all of mine, without expletives, have been censored. I'm still waiting for the outrage for a man who tasers his son, drives his Trooper vehicle after chugging a beer and holding another in his hand, poaches a moose, threatens another man with gun violence, etc., etc., etc. This would be focused, as is the haranguing of Palin, on a single person. It would also be a more worth cause than someone who fires someone for a legitimate reason -- not that she has to have one to begin with.


You've have got to be kidding

Lets see, Law, Integrity, The Truth. How would you like to be Wooten? The rest of us want the truth.


Yes, he's serious

If issues of judgement and character are fair game, then this is serious. 'Do you have nothing else to do'. The fact that you read it (well commented on it) reveals you don't. Now get back to ghost writing those letters to the editor about the scary black Muslim who's fooling 55% of the electorate to vote for him.


Are you serious? No Are YOU serious

I would say that about every state is an at will state, however; does that give business owners, bosses and public officals free reign to abuse that fact? Maybe your boss should fire you for being an uninformed, blind idiot.


Sara 'Soapy Smith' Palin

Fellow bloggers let us not waste time in responding to this tired arguement. "At Will" does not mean you can violate other peoples rights or abuse your power. Take off the Palin covered glasses and open your eyes. The Palin's are a tag team on liars the likes of which Alaska has never seen. I nominate Sara and Todd for the Soapy Smith award for attempting to pull off the greatest Con Job and Scam in our states history.


If you really believe what

If you really believe what you say, then you had better take your head out of the sand and consider the following: a public servant--and that includes the governor--is not entitled to use his or her power over a subordinate to force that person to take a position CONTRARY TO POLICY AND LAW. This is what the Palin administration was trying to do with Monegan who repeatedly said the matter had already been handled according to established department criteria and, as we will see in the report due today, with the workers comp board.


Gov. Palin etc etc.

Love all you do and trust your judgement and love all you write. Looks like Troopergate is your fault???!!!!! What a bunch of lies the Palin's tell. All the manipulations, lies and sneaky deeds that they do, and they get a white-wash. Why in the world would Alaska pay for her sleeping at home?? that is just one perverted thing that they do. I hate the way she treats women, animals and Eskimo/Indians, I hate the way they uses people. They will lose the election, and put us all out of our misery, with having to listen to both of them. The Report is another white-wash, and Alaska better listen to you and the other Alaskans for Truth and send her back to the PTA.


What!?

Palin has NEVER said verbally that she hates women. If that be the case she would kill herself. Duh! Sounds like you don't like her moral beliefs.


Report from McCain Campaign

Andrew, so you're the problem! Now I understand. Thanks to the McCain campaign for explaining it all. Clearly, all that legislative and ethics fuss was for nothing. Seriously, what are they so freakin' worried about? What can possibly justify this level of cover-up? I mean, it seems Todd is willing to take the fall as illogical and unsupported as his story is upon close examination. The over-concerned hubby angle could still play well in a lot of locales. It would have looked bad to some but not to others. But what is it that causes such worry? Interference with the worker's comp claim?


keep up the fight!

i love you andrew. you may be the only person who can stop palin from getting obama assassinated. i can't believe a mother of 4 (5?) lets racists and violent outbursts go unchecked. xo allison


Walt and Andrew

http://townhall.com/news/politics-elections/2008/10/10/palin_pre-empts_state_report,_clears_self_in_probe?page=1 Monegan said Thursday that he doesn't know what to expect from the legislative panel's own report. "I just hope that the truth is figured out," Monegan told The Associated Press on Thursday. "That the governor did want me to fire him, and I chose to not. You just can't walk up to someone and say, 'I fire you.' He didn't do anything under my watch to result in termination." Palin's critics say that shows she used her office to settle family affairs. "When you're the governor, you leave your household hat at home and you become governor," said state Senate President Lyda Green, a Republican who has frequently clashed with Palin. McCain spokesman Taylor Griffin, who distributed the campaign's report, said it was based on public filings and Todd Palin's affidavit. The report blames former campaign opponent, Andrew Halcro, who has a blog, of conspiring with Wooten to pin Monegan's dismissal on the family's dispute with Wooten. Three days after Monegan was fired, they say, Wooten told his ex-wife, Palin's sister, that: "You guys are going down. Get ready for the show." Two days after that confrontation, they say, Halcro and Wooten met at a hotel bar in Anchorage for more than three hours _ and that evening, Halcro posted the first accusations on his blog that Monegan had been fired because of a vendetta against Wooten by the Palin family. "It is tragic that a false story hatched by a blogger after drinks with Trooper Wooten led the legislature to allocate over $100,000 of public money to be spent in what has become a politically driven investigation," the 21-page report concludes


Bloggers neither authoritative or reliable source

Most mainstream media outlets have noted that much of their original information about Governor Palin came from the internet and internet bloggers. MSM was so blind-sided by the VP pick, they had no information available on Governor Palin and went to the internet. Andrew seems to have a lot of information, that he has been talking about on his radio show that a lot of regular Alaskans are not privy to, why is that? Andrew has been talking about this for weeks and has even told his listeners that he has spoken with "most" of the parties involved, presumeably Monegan and Wooten and formed his opinions and framed his remarks based on those communications which may or may not have been entirely truthful. Furthermore, I do not think it is appropriate for individuals who are the number focus of an an ongoing investigation for which Alaskan's paid the tab. None of these "witnesses" should be talking to the press or talk radio personalities until the investigation has been completed. This is not reporting, this is gossip. Monegan from the very beginning said he had no clue why he was offered another position within DPS. Monegan's story changed over time to the one you quoted above. Monegan never said originally, "that the governor did want met to fire him..." That is just not true and if Andrew Halcro and other bloggers and talk radio host want to disseminate this information then they are part of the problem not the solution. Interestingly, from Todd Palin's testimony, apparently Monegan had never met Trooper Wooten or even knew what he looked like. Additionally, the Todd Palin's testimony reveals what one could perceive as personal attacks on Governor Palin, including a reference to Governor Palin not putting baby Trig in a car seat and a rather "awkward" email sent to the Governor from Monegan. Toward the end it seems that the Governor and Monegan just had too little in common politically or peronally. I too would be highly offended if one of my employees made a false accusation about the way I care for my newborn child without asking me first.


Jim is fading

Jim, You didn't even post anything original this time. You just paraphrased the McCain campaign's last ditch desperate attempt to divert attention. Andrew should pick up another job as a cold case investigator if he can find the time. He has done a remarkable job of putting the pieces in place on this entire fiasco.


Halcro Slimed!!!

haha mr. halcro, the mccain campaign is at it again. they will slime anyone who gets in their way. The campaign's report instead blames former campaign opponent, Andrew Halcro, who has a blog, of conspiring with Wooten to pin Monegan's dismissal on the family's dispute with Wooten. Three days after Monegan was fired, they say, Wooten told his ex-wife, Palin's sister, that: "You guys are going down. Get ready for the show." Two days after that confrontation, they say, Halcro and Wooten met at a hotel bar in Anchorage for more than three hours — and that evening, Halcro posted the first accusations on his blog that Monegan had been fired because of a vendetta against Wooten by the Palin family. "It is tragic that a false story hatched by a blogger after drinks with Trooper Wooten led the legislature to allocate over $100,000 of public money to be spent in what has become a politically driven investigation," the 21-page report concludes. from AP


Not Fair

Those that follow you Andrew know that you take great pains to research and print the truth. Thanks for being there. Sarah could have avoided this whole mess by coming clean early and apologizing. That was poor judgment or poor counsel. The sad thing for me is that we have an even worse alternative on the national stage. I know that as both an honest guy and a conservative, that the collective reality of all this has got to eat at your insides - it does mine. Thanks for your work and don't concern yourself with attack. What should be of some concern is some of the new, liberal folks that now think they are your good buddies. I wish you could also devote your tenacity for finding and exposing truth to the big-smooth-impostor Barrack Obama. The economy and culture of the USA is in big trouble if the polling-trends continue. The latest voter fraud associated with Obama's ACORN is frightening. It is too bad there are not more people of the caliber of you Andrew. SS


The Man Who Knew Too Much

Andrew, I'm glad you came forward with the truth and I am sorry you are now getting slimed by a political campaign and a badly run one at that. I'm hoping the report will lead to criminal charges because I see at least one felony already in this weird saga of a back woods family feud. I suppose that what ever the outcome of Branchflower's report, you will be kept in SarahandTodd Palin's and the McCain campaign's gun sights for some time into the future. I'm sorry you have to go through all of that but I have faith that you are the type of man who will hold strong.


Sarah Palin said publically she did not do THIS

Palins Repeatedly Pressed Case Against Trooper

Alaska’s former public safety commissioner was contacted three dozen times by Gov. Sarah Palin, her husband and seven administration officials about the status of one of his troopers, interviews and documents show.


troopergate

Just think-you may be personally responsible for saving the free world from yet another clueless administration! Thank you in advance.


Now It's All Your Fault, Andrew

Please respond to the Personnel Committee/McCain Campaign report. From the AP story, it sounds so transparently like a white wash I can't imagine anyone with an ounce of political judgment releasing it.


NEW! Subscribe to RSS Feed


copyright 2007 Andrew Halcro, All Rights Reserved.